Katrina Simon
11 December 2014
Sustainable Systems
Solving the Wicked Meat Industry Problems
According to a report by Worldwatch Institute, more than 51% of global greenhouse gas emissions are caused by animal agriculture. Not only does it add to global warming, the pesticides, fertilizer, fuel, feed and water used are also effecting the air, water, and soil. The meat industry’s use of factory farming is a form of animal cruelty, in the way that they house and treat animals and also by genetically altering them. Don’t think there are enough reasons why meat/the meat industry is so bad? Here’s another one- meat has been the source of many health issues in humans because of the bacteria and antibiotics found in animals. The meat industry has been causing environmental problems but what makes this a “wicked problem” and injustice are because of the ethical issues regarding the treatment of animals and health issues to those that consume it. It seems like factory farming/the meat industry is negatively affecting so many aspects of our daily lives.
Raising animals for food, like using land for gazing and to grow animal feed crops, uses 30% of the Earth’s land mass. Since there is about 520 million square kilometers of landmass on Earth, which means that 153 million square kilometers is used for raising animals. Seeing the actual number of how much land that is holds a lot more emotion and effect than hearing the percentage of land it is. Its not just using a lot of land, it is damaging a lot of land. 260 million acres of this amount of land was forests that were cleared to create cropland to grow animal feed (Meat Production Wastes Natural Resources). In a 2009 study, it was found that four-fifths of the deforestation across the Amazon rainforest could be linked to factory farming of cattle (Scheer).
Water pollution for factory farms is also a huge environmental problem that has been occurring. Animal agriculture uses one third of the world’s fresh water (Walsh). Half of all water in the United States is used to raise animals for food. This amount of water is used through many different aspects of the factory farming process, from growing cattle feed to giving cattle fresh water to drink. Many animals consume feed that is primarily corn. Corn is a plant that actually requires a lot of water for growth. 7,000-8,000 gallons of water are lost daily through the water evaporation in the corn. Corn needs to be watered more often than other plants because it has short, shallow roots, which also results in more water consumption (Environmental Impact). It takes 2,400 gallons of water to produce 1 pound of meat. Factory farming uses an excessive amount of water, but also results in water pollution. The manure or animal urine/feces that is produced in factory farming is so much in such a small space that it up getting into water systems. These results in polluted water that can be very dangerous for humans, making us sick or in many cases can be fatal. Antibiotics that are pumped into animals also ends up being found in water as well, which is not healthy for humans and fish to be consuming. Shocking statistics about this shows says that chicken, hog and cattle excrement has polluted 35,000 miles of rivers in 22 states and groundwater in 17 states, according to the EPA. To give an example of a situation where the water was polluted, in 1995 25 million gallons of hog urine and feces spilled into a river in North Carolina where 10-14 million fish died instantly (Meat Production Wastes Natural Resources).
The amount of chemicals that is found in many parts of the meat process is startling. Like I stated before, the antibiotics that are given to animals end up being found in our water as well since it ends up in animal excrement, which has been polluting water sources. Livestock are usually fed corn, soybean meal or other grains that are grown with a lot of fertilizer and pesticides. According to the Environmental Working Group, livestock feed in the U.S. requires 167 million pounds of pesticides and 17 billion pounds of nitrogen fertilizer each year across 149 million acres of fields of crops (Scheer).
It is known that antibiotics are found in most animals because of the conditions of factory farming. Some say that 70% of all antibiotics are mixed into animal feed to prevent disease in animals when they are raised in factory farming conditions, which consist of close quarters and too many animals shoved together in one area. Not only do the antibiotics decrease losses of animals from disease, it also accelerates growth of animals. For example, chickens have been grown larger and larger to provide cheaper chicken to mass-produce. The pumping of antibiotics into our animals is not healthy for the animal, as well as for humans. This means that the meat we eat is filled with antibiotics that we then consume. With the overuse and misuse of antibiotics means that bacteria will become resistant to them and they will not be used in the way that we need them- to keep us healthy and protected from very dangerous bacteria (Hal).
The actual make up of red meat is very unhealthy for humans, even when it is not pumped with antibiotics. Carnitine is found in read meat and it has been known to cause atherosclerosis, which is hardening or clogging arteries. According to a report in JAMA International Medicine, eating red meat can increase the risk of developing type two diabetes. “Specifically, 3.5 ounces of red meat or 1.8 ounces of processed meat daily can lead to a 19% and 51% increase in diabetes risk.” Meat also contains a lot of iron. Eating too much iron increases the risk of developing Alzheimer’s. This is because when iron builds up in the brain, myelin (a fatty tissue that coats nerve fibers) is destroyed. Destroying them affects the brain tissues and brain communication, which therefore causes Alzheimer’s. The hormones added to red meat increase the risk of breast cancer. According to a study, women who ate more than 1.5 servings of red meat per day had nearly double the risk of developing breast cancer than women who ate 3 or fewer servings per week (Melone).
The treatment of animals in how the meat industry is currently run is (in my eyes, and many others’) extremely cruel. In factory farms, animals are crammed into small spaces with no windows and feces covered on the ground, resulting in disease in animals. They are given drugs to fatten up fast and stay alive in conditions that would normally kill them. Animals are also deprived of exercise so that all the energy goes towards producing meat, flesh, eggs, or milk for humans to eat (Factory Farming: Cruelty to Animals). Factory farming has also recreated the chicken (and other animals) physically so that they have larger breasts. Making the chicken fatter in a shorter amount of time has caused chickens to not be able to walk around for more than a couple steps until they have to stop. They cannot hold themselves up because they do not have the muscle to do so and are too big. This problem is also happening in cows. Since lean meat is so desirable, farmers are not having their cows exercise much so meat stays lean. This results in cows that are not able to hold themselves up, the same problem that is occurring in cows. Mercy for Animals is an organization that has exposed animal cruelty in factory farming and is trying to prevent this from continuing to occur. It is really interesting to read the investigations that they have done; for instance this year they looked into Butterball again in North Carolina. They found that baby turkeys had their toes and beaks cut and burned off without any painkillers and workers were throwing and dropping animals, and grinding up animals alive (Undercover Investigations of Factory Farms and Slaughterhouses). The conditions animals are being treated in factory farms are revolting and should be stopped.
There is a lot of air pollution that is caused by cattle and meat industry/factory farming practices. Livestock are fed usually corn and soybean. To make this feed, it takes about 167 million pounds of pesticides and 17 billion pounds of nitrogen fertilizer each year. This process creates nitrous oxide, a greenhouse gas that’s 300 times more powerful than carbon dioxide. Methane is also created from livestock’s flatulence and manure as it decomposes. It is estimated that 20% of all U.S. methane emissions is from the meat industry/cattle. Red meat is responsible for 10 to 40 times as much greenhouse gas emissions as the growing of vegetables and grains (Scheer).
The meat industry is causing many environmental problems, health problems and brings up ethical issues regarding the treatment of animals, making this a “wicked problem.” One of the easiest ways to try and fix this problem is to stop eating so much meat. If everyone were to just cut down on meat consumption, this would result in fewer cows needing to be farmed, less environmental problems and will help your health greatly. Other ways are to stop pumping antibiotics into animals. My invention is to have cow “pants” so when cows flatulent is released, it goes into a tank so methane is not released into the air, it can be used as an energy source, and this is also a way where cows can roam free but still stay in a lot- also solving animal cruelty problems. My product could be a way where we can try to fix this wicked problem.
Work Cited
“Environmental Impact.” StopForceFeeding.com. Animal Protection & Rescue League, n.d. Web. 05 Dec. 2014.
“Factory Farming: Cruelty to Animals.” PETA. PETA, n.d. Web. 09 Dec. 2014.
Hal, Robert W. “Antibiotics and Wicked Problems.” Compression Institute. N.p., 8 Sept. 2010. Web. 7 Dec. 2014.
“Meat Production Wastes Natural Resources.” PETA. PETA, n.d. Web. 02 Dec. 2014.
Melone, Linda. “10 Reasons To Stop Eating Red Meat.” Prevention. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Dec. 2014.
Scheer, Roddy, and Doug Moss. “How Does Meat in the Diet Take an Environmental Toll?” Scientific American. The Environmental Magazine, 28 Dec. 2011. Web. 05 Dec. 2014.
“Undercover Investigations of Factory Farms and Slaughterhouses.” Mercy for Animals. Mercy for Animals, n.d. Web. 9 Dec. 2014.
Walsh, Bryan. “The Triple Whopper Environmental Impact of Global Meat Production.” Time. Time, 16 Dec. 2013. Web. 04 Dec. 2014.