Tag Archives: circle line tour

Water Field Experience Follow Up

New York City is surrounded by water, so it is no surprise that water is an important part of the city. While watching WATER by Eric Goldstein, I learned that the Dutch and English settled in New York City because of the water. It is great location for commerce and trading. For drinking water, the Dutch and English used well water, ponds and springs or drank beer because the Hudson River was extremely polluted from dumping sewer and waste. Its interesting to note that the Hudson river is still very polluted today, showing how long this problem has been going on in New York City. While on the Cruise Line Harbor tour I saw first hand how polluted the water is, seeing actual garbage float around but also by seeing how dirty it is. At home, I lived near the Charles River in Massachusetts. This river is extremely different from the Hudson because it is not very polluted. The water that we drink from my house is filtered water from the Charles River.

According to Eric Goldstein, the Catskill Mountains are where the reservoirs were built and are still used for New York City water. About 1.1 billion gallons of drinking water a day comes from this reservoir. This water is unfiltered yet extremely clean, but it is endangered from pollutions that come from factories, sewer plants, and runoff water. Another important factor about the reservoir is that it does not use any energy to get the water from the Catskills to New York City. Only gravity is used to transport it, meaning that it is extremely sustainable and ecofriendly.

Throughout the world, wild oyster reefs have been severely impacted by the amount of pollution, 85% of oyster reefs are gone. According to the video, Shell Shocked, the Hudson River use to be the oyster capital of the world. It was economically and environmentally extremely important for the city. The oysters helped the ecosystem in the Hudson River; there were many other fish and animals in the water, stemming back to the need of the oysters. One oyster can filter fifty gallons of water a day, so this was keeping the water extremely clean. Oysters were eaten by most people, which made it an important export for the city. Oyster shells were also ground up and made into brick for buildings. Because of all the waste dumping into the river, oyster beds became polluted and were infected with disease, making people sick when they would eat them. This has hurt other organisms and fish in the water as well.

There is a movement to try and get oysters back into the Hudson River. One artist is making oyster shells out of nontoxic, natural materials like porcelain or marble, for oyster larvae to have a place to settle on. The water is so acidic that the oysters couldn’t live in the water anymore because the acid would eat the shells. The hope is that the oyster larvae in the water now can land on the man made shells and start producing oyster beds again. There is also the Billion Oyster movement that is happening to try and bring oysters back to the Hudson in hopes that it will help filter out the water and create a cleaner river.

Bhawani Venkataraman is a professor at The New School and talked about the chemistry of water and why it is so important. As most know, water is essential for life. We take for granted that water is a liquid, because if it was anything else we wouldn’t be able to survive. This is why treatment plants are so important because having safe water is needed for survival. This is also why it is such an important issue around the world that everyone should have access to clean water, especially in third world countries like Africa. To have safe water, there needs to be an analysis of water and then determine if there are threts for the water and if so, what level threat there is. The Safe Drinking Water Act established maximum levels of toxins to still be safe, drinking water. In New York City, there are water sampling stations after water is treated at the water treatment plant to make sure that the water still meets the standards after coming from the underground pipes.

It is interesting to note the difference between bottled water and tap water. Citizens of New York pay in their taxes for the disinfecting and treatment of water to make it clean and drinkable. This means that tap water is roughly $0.07 cents per cup, equaling 1 cent per gallon. Bottled water in New York City is around $2, and it is basically the exact same thing.

Kate Zidar is apart of the Newtown Creek Alliance so she was able to speak directly about the Newtown Water Treatment Plant. This is the most polluted area in New York City because it used to be the area for heavy industry. It is now mostly distribution centers. 720,000,000 gallons of water a day are processed in Newtown Creek. It is interesting to think about how much water New York City uses, how much waste is produced, and how much needs to be disinfected before being able to be used again.

Water Field Experience

MAP:map copy

OBSERVATIONS/SITES:

1. This is the site of the Newtown Creek Waste Water Treatment Facility taken at 5:25. Not only the complexity of the entire system shocked me, but the actual shape of these specific “egg” looking structures was intriguing. I was wondering if maybe the structure has to be this shape because of the specific process to clean the water? Interesting to note that 1.4 billion gallons of water are processed in one day here.

IMG_1697

2. This was taken at the site of the Newtown Creek Water Waste Facility at 5:20. This specific circular instrument in the right hand corner of the picture intrigued me. What exactly is the role of it is in the process to make the water clean?

IMG_1716

3. These pictures were taken at 5:15 of the trash area while traveling through the Newtown Creek. I was shocked with the amount of trash. I had trouble hearing on the trip so I think I missed the explanation of what exactly this place is but it was crazy to see this amount of waste in one place… and then to realize that this is only the tiniest little bit of the waste in the whole world.

IMG_1684 IMG_1685 IMG_1691

4. This photo was taken at 5:12 while traveling down the Newtown Creek to get to the Waste Water Treatment Plant. I took a picture of it because of the name. The trucks have “City of Harvest” written on them. I was interested in what this means, and if it is a company that works for the city of New York to help sustainability or possibly something with farming.

IMG_1670

5. This photo was taken at 4:50 near Governor’s Island. Yes it is the type of iconic Statue of Liberty picture, but I took it for more reasons than just that. I was curious if landfill has increased the island that the Statue of Liberty stands on like it has to the coastline of Manhattan. I also took this photo because the water seems so beautiful and clear which seemed ironic because the water is actually extremely gross and polluted.

IMG_1662

 

OBSERVATIONS WITHOUT PICTURES:

  • rainwater and human waste is combined in the same pipe(s)… seems very inefficient
  • water isn’t clean- I saw pieces of garbage floating around many times
  • lots of boats out on the water- all using gas/oil that is probably adding to the water pollution

 

GUIDED QUESTIONS:

  • In what ways did we experience water?

We were experience water because we were on a boat, so though a transportation way. Also a human/land system and water relationship was seen through the piers where businesses sometimes have storage/areas there, wastewater treatment plants- specifically seeing Newtown Creek plant, many bridges we passes, and other boats and how they interact with each other.

  • How is freshwater connected to the urban ecosystem?

Freshwater is connected to the urban ecosystem through the usage of waste water treatment plants and facilities. Using technology and these plants, urban areas are able to get freshwater even though the waste and sewer pipes are not set up in the best way possible for the city (which ends up with sewer potentially in the water).

  • What evidence did you collect to ascertain the health/quality of the Lower Hudson River/New York Harbor estuary?

I saw that the health/quality of the Lower Hudson River/New York Harbor estuary is not very high. In the water, I could see waste in it at points during the trip. Buildings along the trip looked like they were in very poor condition and that paint from the buildings and possibly parts of them were going into the water. There was very little evidence of wildlife, which also makes me come to this conclusion. What I know about the oyster project off of Governor’s Island tells me that the Hudson is not a very clean river.

  • What new evidence would you collect to help ascertain water quality, in light of these biological, chemical, and physical factors we observed?

I would want to test the water for specific chemicals to try and understand what exactly is polluting the water and making it so awful. I would want to know more of the hard facts about what exactly is in the water.